Choosing an appropriate graph

A good graph makes the intended comparison clear. Start with the question, not your favourite chart style.

Lesson 02 · Statistics
Your learning goal

Choose a representation that suits the data, the context and the question being investigated.

Match the graph to its purpose

A bar graph compares amounts in categories. A double bar graph compares the same categories across two groups using a shared scale. A line graph shows change across an ordered numerical variable, often time. A circle graph shows non-overlapping parts of one whole. These are choices for communicating a relationship, not rules based only on how the graph looks.

Time needs honest spacing

For measurements at equally spaced times, equally spaced positions on the horizontal axis are appropriate. If observations occur on days 1, 2 and 10, placing all three points at equal distances hides the long gap. A connecting line suggests a progression between observations; it does not prove that the intermediate values were measured.

A whole must really be a whole

Circle graphs work when every part belongs to the same total and categories do not overlap. If students can select several favourite sports, category percentages may sum to more than 100%. A circle graph would falsely imply one partition of a whole; a bar graph can show the number choosing each option. Always state whether percentages refer to respondents or total selections.

Two sensible choices can answer different questions

The same weekly sales data can be displayed as bars to compare individual days or as a line to emphasise change over time. Justify the choice using the question. ‘It looks nice’ is a preference; ‘it makes the Tuesday-to-Friday change easy to follow’ is a mathematical reason.

Explore · predict, test, explain

Make your thinking visible.

Graph Lab

Enter one label and value per line, separated by a comma. This tool supports 2–12 non-negative values. The table and graph always use the same data.

Line graphs use equally spaced positions here: use observations at equal time intervals. Do not use a line to connect unrelated categories. Circle graphs require a positive total.

Worked examples

Follow the reasoning.

Friday lunch orders

  1. Pizza: 24 orders, wraps: 18 orders, salad: 8 orders. Total: 50 orders.
  2. A bar graph compares the three category counts directly.
  3. A circle graph could show shares: 48%, 36% and 16%, provided these are all orders and each order belongs to one category.
  4. For a restocking decision, category counts may be more useful than percentages alone.

Tracking a cooling drink

  1. Record the temperature every two minutes using degrees Celsius.
  2. Use time on the horizontal axis and temperature on the vertical axis.
  3. A line graph makes the changing temperature easier to follow.
  4. A circle graph is unsuitable: temperatures are not parts of a meaningful total.
Guided Practice

Build an explanation.

You need to compare boys’ and girls’ goal totals in Grades 6–9. What representation could help?

Give me a hint

The same grade categories occur in two groups.

Compare a worked response

A double bar graph places each pair beside one another on the same scale. Include a legend, grade labels and units. Keep the groups’ definitions and counting periods consistent.

Can daily high temperatures be put in a circle graph?

Give me a hint

What would the whole represent?

Compare a worked response

Adding temperatures does not form a meaningful whole to partition. Use a line graph for a time pattern or bars for individual-day comparisons.

Independent Practice

Test the idea, then check your reasoning.

Feedback explains your chosen response. These activities are practice, not a school mark.

1. Which choice best shows a measured water temperature changing over ten minutes?

2. Students may choose several clubs. Counts add to 140 selections for 90 students. Which graph is defensible?

Connections

Use it beyond this page.

Use the original Graphing Tasks package: compare the gaming teams, follow the homeroom step patterns and investigate lunch preferences. Select a graph because it answers the task’s question.

Take it further

Display one dataset as both bars and a circle graph. Write one question each representation answers especially well, and one detail that is harder to judge.

What are you curious about?

Search lessons, class notes and interesting questions.